I'm Ari Pinkus, associate editor at NAIS, and I'll be reporting on the environmental sustainability summit throughout the week.
As I reflect on this summit, I must make a confession. At the kick-off dinner, when Dan Garvey asked participants to stand if we were hopeful about the planet’s future, I didn’t stand up. A news and information junkie, I thought things were looking bleak.
But the experiences of this week have shifted my perspective. I was heartened to hear sustainability moving beyond the sciences into the ethical and social realm. In my view, inclusivity and equity are key to this movement. Bringing the point home was a lunchroom conversation: one participant told others at the table about Israelis and Palestinians finding common ground on sustainability concerns. Also, the idea of buildings on campus being “green” teaching tools was eye-opening. I saw the immediacy and proximity of place-based education. I was moved as we toured the farm and noticed the affection between two Hotchkiss graduates as they shared how much they grew and how they wanted to pay it forward. I marveled at the biomass plant at Hotchkiss and solar panel array at Berkshire. The data and fact geek in me appreciated the range of metrics in the STARS system, designed to evaluate sustainability. I see much potential for progress by using it.
Mostly, I was struck by the participants’ energy, passion, and creative thinking as I was witnessing lives being lived with deep purpose. I feel privileged to have spent a little time among leaders – true change agents – committed to working together to build a better world, one idea at a time. And I am newly committed to doing my part toward that end.
I carry a fresh sense of hope now.
Day 3: Tweets from the Summit Street
First up, Julie Newman of Yale’s Sustainability Ctr
See goal paradox: growing campus, reducing resource use
Coins phrase: science of sustainability change management
Be aware of mission statement, hierarchy, decision-making
Know where you fit in your school’s org chart
See tensions: foundation v. vision, incremental v. systematic, short- v. long-term
Can’t just be environmentalist yelling recycle
Use all chances to bring other depts. together
Required to sit in endless meetings? Learn, learn from architects, others
Propose changes from your learnings
Streamline building design process
Always push needle a little further
Achieved LEED Gold? Develop living building
Use a public progress report for accountabililty
Julie got from 1 goal to 43 b/c of buy-in from leaders. Wow!
Attendees share in open space sessions
Consider diversity & equity in sustainability
Reach out to inner-city schools
Have kids do cost comparison of foods in high & lower-end markets
Not about navel gazing, prettifying but working for greater good
Employees’ compensation big piece of sustainability
Sustainability not one person’s responsibility but everyone’s
Working self out of ‘sustainability’ job
How to make everyone feel empowered?
Show me the greenbacks….
What’s sexy to donors: funding peddle-a-watt bike kits
As kids ride, bike generates electricity & meter reads how much
Consider green revolving fund, popular in higher ed
Invest in green campus projects and use savings to invest in others
Can bundle projects, too
To donors: Your $ will be used in perpetuity, keep letting us buy new needs
Green revolving fund helped one org get grant
Craig Wescott, dir of Samson Enviro Ctr and part of growing.greener, speaks
Darrow School’s growing.greener initiative raised $2.5M
2008 market crash spurred Craig’s idea forward
One giver, two types of gifts: annual fund, growing.greener
Lots of 1800s buildings would be lost without changes
Securing the future, preserving the past
FEMA donated $ to protect structures after hurricanes ravaged other areas
Growing.greener created 20-stop walking tour
See interior storm windows, attic insulation, etc.
Growing.greener big presence at Earth Day event
Telecom problem folded into growing.greener
B/c without Internet, no business plan, no future
Ensure donors can follow their money to project
On yellow bus to Berkshire School to see solar array
Cool scene! 8,000 solar panels, 8 acres, 2 Megawatts
Frank Barros of Berkshire: It fills 40% of school’s electric needs
Four students presented climate action plan to Board
Building company, PowerPlay Solar, was run by a student’s parent
One donor owned panels, now many do: Friends of Berkshire
Berkshire pays locked-in price of $.09/kilowatt
1st donor’s ROI is in ~ 8 yrs
Berkshire trailblazer in adopting STARS to measure sustainability
Measures: operations, administration, education & research
Inc. things like: curriculum, climate, public engagement
Now one of nine high schools w/ STARS; Hotchkiss another
Princeton Review & Sierra Club use STARS to rate colleges’ sustainability
Recent grad talks school’s STARS, turns heads at Yale
Barros trumpets transparency and quality w/ STARS
Create a challenge among rival schools? Food for thought.
Dinner at the barn on the Hotchkiss farm
Andy Cox, general manager of Hotchkiss Dining Srvics/Sedexo Campus Srvics, talks food
Hotchkiss in the real food challenge
Real food = what nature gives us
Plants, roots, nuts, fruits, seeds, meats, eggs, milk
Now, 37% of Hotchkiss food is real, up from 13% two years ago
Local, local, local…
Tonite’s menu: Smoked brisket (for 9 hrs!), local smoked Portobello mushroom,
Baked cranberry merlot beans, local corn succotash, mac & cheddar w/ local kale
For dessert: bread pudding and ice cream. Yum!
Day 2: Weaving Sustainability into Curriculum
Summit participants learned about ways to integrate sustainability into the school curriculum. As part of this discussion, they toured Hotchkiss’s carbon neutral biomass facility, a key teaching tool and the source of the school’s heat and hot water from October – April each year. The curriculum conversation came full circle upon a visit to the school’s working farm, where newly minted Hotchkiss graduates and current students expressed their enthusiasm for caring for the land and cultivating a work ethic.
Speakers were Sarah Kadden, EFS partnership coordinator at Shelburne Farms in Vermont; Mark Biedron, co-director of the Willow School in New Jersey; Torrey McMillan, director of the Center for Sustainability at the Hathaway Brown School in Ohio; and Bill Wiecking, director of the HPA Energy Lab at Hawaii Preparatory Academy.
Key takeaways on infusing sustainability into the curriculum to consider:
- Sustainability’s definition: improving the quality of life, economically, socially, and environmentally for all, now and future generations;
- Navigate organization to obtain firm backing from administration and trustees;
- Create and nurture collaborations (in the school and the community) to the point at which collective impact is possible;
- Capitalize on students natural capacity to wonder (inquire and make connections) to gain understanding to be responsible to take action now and in the future;
- Have students become the change agents for sustainability: have them take on projects, including researching where school materials and food are coming from, writing reports and recommendations to administration and local political leaders;
- Play up placed-based education right at your school, including exposing the school’s heating and plumbing systems to use them as teaching tools;
- Make the case that sustainability courses are the most rigorous for college admissions officers;
- Look at sustainability not just through the sciences but with an ethical and humanistic lens, surfacing issues such as regeneration, diversity, and equity;
- Encourage deep and creative thinking, and don't force-feed information to stakeholders;
- Look out over the long-term and beyond the problems that exist today;
- Develop a holistic curriculum approach in which teachers in different subject areas take up the same sustainability idea in a variety of ways: writing, drawing, singing, building;
- Create a firm link between theory (conceptual, interdisciplinary) and action (skills and processes) by which changing behavior becomes possible;
- Infuse sustainability into the curriculum early in a student’s study;
- Cross-list sustainability with another subject area;
- Look at sustainability’s future in schools by looking at a recent example: how technology came to be embraced in schools, becoming a department and a budget line item; and
- See sustainability metrics as a way to move in the right direction
Key insights from sustainability design experts Stacy Smedley, executive director of the Sprout! Collective and the SEED Project; Daniela Holt Volith, Voith & Mactavish; and Alan Paradis, Centerbrook Architects & Planners, LLP:
- Create a living building: greenhouse, rain collection facility, composting toilet, garden, 100 percent nontoxic;
- Involve students in the design;
- Expose structure and finishes - don’t bury wires and tubing;
- Have students track all materials back to their sources;
- Retrofit existing classrooms;
- As yourself, what do we really need? When and how is it going to be used?
- Make spaces multifunctional;
- Be flexible and share;
- Work on a landscape master plan;
- Note that many of the leading energy-saving strategies are the least costly;
- Take a holistic approach: reduce energy consumption, respect materials, nature, and site; minimize construction, maximize use;
- Make the most use of light with materials and design;
- Consider the following environmental design priorities
- Occupant health and well-being;
- Institutional mission;
- Energy efficiency;
- Maximum LEED certification;
- Minimum carbon footprint;
- Minimum life-cycle costs; and
Keep overall purpose in mind: designing buildings to become beloved and lasting structures
During the day, participants described some opportunities and challenges in sustainability:
- Sharing knowledge with others in the field through common repository: website, database
- Maintaining connections with like-minded people
- Receiving buy-in from their Board, faculty, administration, and students
- Obtaining funds for sustainable initiatives
- Receiving “green” awards to set a standard and achieve buy-in
We are grateful for Sodexo’s support of the Summit on Environmental Sustainability and of the independent school community!
Day 1: Are we winning or losing the battle?
That’s the question Dan Garvey, president emeritus of Prescott College in Arizona, principally asked the summit participants to ponder in the Summit’s kick-off session.
A conversation he overheard between two fellow air travelers was disconcerting: they were still debating global warming, Garvey said. He wondered aloud: How did we lose them?
In many ways, the data about the state of the environment is troubling: Consider Dennis Meadows’s Limits of Growth that the carrying capacity of the planet is reaching its limits. He noted a study that this generation of high school and college students is not as concerned about the environment as prior generations had been.
Nonetheless, Garvey sees data that supports the opposite. “We’re on the threshold of a renaissance,” he said, adding that when institutions fail, humans evolve and change the system.
A grandfather looking at his grandchild, he said, “The world you will inherit is much better than the world as I have it because our species is made that way.”
The challenge for us is that the meme (a meme encompasses the entirety of one’s belief system and a community’s belief system) we belong to is competing with others out there and there isn’t much overlap. We’re all thinking and operating independently, and we tend to be suspect of one another.
He took a pep-talk like tone as he encouraged attendees to shift their thinking.
Reach out to each other (in other memes), he said, and collaborate with others. Seek leadership positions and use them wisely. Be ambassadors of hope and mean it, he said. “We painted a picture of veritable environmental Armageddon, and we wondered why people didn’t follow us to a better place.” The problem with that scenario? We were under the false impression that when ignorance is a problem, information is the solution. But that’s not how it works, as the rise in smoking among young women demonstrates. When people face criticism, they tend to flee from it, he noted.
He noted that Summit attendees are in the strata that moves the needle. Cases in point, Outward Bound and experiential learning haven’t happened for the most part at nonpublic schools. This thinking came to independent schools. “When we say things are good, the rest of society takes a look,” he said.
Overall, Garvey’s optimism was palpable. “Have faith and a lot of confidence in what you do, in what we do,” he said.
Tuesday, June 25
And Off to the Enviro Summit We Go!
I engaged summit organizers Jefferson Burnett, vice president for government and community relations at NAIS, and Wynn Calder, director of Sustainable Schools LLC, in a bit of Q & A car talk, prompting them to share some background and expectations for the summit this week.